The clinical evaluation of vertical root fracture after endodontic treatment with mineral trioxide aggregate

Introduction: Vertical root fractures (VRFs) in endodontic treatment teeth are most serious complication. VRFs have a poor prognosis and usually result in tooth extraction. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical outcomes of mineral trioxide aggregate (MTA) filled teeth for VRFs using by dental operate microscope (DOM). Methods: Fifty-two endodontic treatment teeth with VRFs were evaluated. 52 VRFs teeth were examined and evaluated the clinical finding with radiography, and DOM finding in root canal. The MTA-filled adhesion methods consist of the elimination of infected dentin by ultrasonic root canal instrument under DOM. The elimination of infected dentin method could be expected to inhibit the root perforation using an apex locator for measuring the distance to the tooth root surface during grooving for enlarging the tooth crack and fracture. Results: 52 VRFs teeth were treated by this method under ODM. Clinical symptoms and radiographic appearance of bony lesions were followed-up from 8 to 90 months. The survival rate of treatment was 94.3%. Conclusion: The results showed the MTA-filled adhesion methods using DOM and ultrasonic instrument was effective therapy for vertical root fractures teeth without extraction of the tooth.


Introduction
Vertical root fractures (VRFs) of endodontic treatment teeth are often encountered in the dental retreatment [1]. Clinical diagnosis of VRFs is difficult because in only a few cases can the presence of a fracture line be detected correctly with radiographic or oral examination. The prognosis of teeth with VRFs is hopeless, and these teeth usually require the extraction of tooth or resection of the affected root. Main factors which lead to extraction are bacterial infection in the fracture line, as well as resorption of nearby alveolar bone. However, an early is necessary to avoid excessive bone loss, which can impair reconstructive procedures should implant therapy be the treatment of choice.
Although several treatment approach have been used to preserve VRFs cases, such as utilizing CO 2 laser to fuse VRFs [2], and intentional re-plantation with adhesive resin cement [3][4][5], no specific treatment has been provided ideal long term results. VRFs reconstruction with adhesive resin cement has shown successful outcome in several studies [6][7][8][9]. The distance between separated fragments, vertical bone defect localization, the position and the extent of the fracture are important factors to determine the treatment modality.
MTA might have a profound advantage when used as canal obturation material because of its superior physiochemical and bioactive properties. MTA also provides an effective seal against dentin and cementum and promotes biologic repair and regeneration of the periodontal ligament [10][11][12][13]. Furthermore, MTA has been shown to support the tooth structure and increase its obturate immature sheep teeth and standardized models of immature teeth made from bovine teeth and bovine femur bone [14]. Recently research has demonstrated that root canal treated teeth obturated with MTA exhibit higher fracture resistance than their untreated counter parts [15].
Recent research on immature tooth models that were obturated with MTA and tested for fracture strength by using an Instron testing machine indicated that at 1 year, MTA showed higher fracture resistance than untreated control [16,17]. MTA increase the resistance to VRFs of endodontically treated teeth and influences the mode of fracture. Furthermore, recently reports might indicate that the combination of calcium hydroxide therapy followed by the obturation of teeth with MTA and combined with a composite core might increase the longterm prognosis for teeth with open apices and necrosis pulps [18][19][20].
Thus, early identification of VRFs by dental operate microscope (DOM) and reconstruction with MTA are important for prognosis of VRFs cases. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical outcomes of MTA-filled teeth for VRFs using by ODM.

Study population and clinical finding
and the radiographic lesion. The radiographs were exposed using a standardized long-cone technique. All the patients were recalled at an interval of 3-6 months for maintenance (Figures 1, 2).

Statistical analysis
Statistical analysis was performed using Stat View (Abacus Concepts, CA, USA). Clinical parameters of the fractured teeth were compared between before treatment and after treatment at recall. Because an insufficient number of teeth were available with follow-up of more than 6 months, only the first year data were included in the statistical analysis. Differences within the groups for pain on percussion, sinus tracts, gingival swelling, increased pocket depth, the presence of radiographic lesions, and remaining tooth number were evaluated using Chi-squaire test with Yetes correction, and residual analysis, with individual variances computed for each comparison. A P value < 0.05 was considered to be statistically significant. Survival curves were created using the Kaplane-Meier method and the Wilcoxon t-test was used to examine differences between premolar and molar tooth group (p<0.05), the patients, and written informed consent statements were received. The UMIN trial was registered at national medical schools in Japan, sponsored by the Ministry of Education, Culture, Science, Sports and Technology (MEXT), Japan (Clinical Trials.gov.) #R000030480 and Current Controlled Trials UMIN000026540.
Fifty two patients who had root canal treatment completed on their VRFs teeth, at Kanagawa Dental University from May 2006 to June 2015, were recalled from 6 to 90 months review by two endodontists. Fifty two VRFs teeth in 52 patients (24 -62 years) with percussion pain and clinical symptoms suggestive of VRF teeth were included in the study after informed consent was obtained. A total of 52 VRFs teeth were examined and evaluated the clinical finding with radiography. VRFs were diagnosis by detection of the fracture line with visual inspection under x8.0 -x16.0 magnification by DOM finding in root canal treatment.

Treatment method
A total of 52 VRF teeth were sealed through the root canal obturation without tooth extraction. Firstly, Root-canal treatment was performed with rubber dam isolation under DOM. All root canal was established the working length to fracture areas, the infected dentin or obturation material was eliminated using #3-5 Gates-Glidden drill (MANI Co., Utsunomiya, Japan) or Peeso reamer (MANI Co.,), and ultrasonic ENDO file (SC.4, OSADA Co., Tokyo, Japan) devices. Infected dentin was stained by 1% acid red in propylene glycol (Kuraray Co., Tokyo, Japan). The elimination of infected dentin method could be expected to inhibit the root perforation using an apex locator for measuring the distance to the tooth root surface during grooving for enlarging the tooth cracks. The root canal cleaning was performed with 5.25% sodium hypochlorite after elimination of infected dentin.
The root canal was dried with paper points, and a calcium hydroxide paste was inserted to or 1 mm short of the working length. When the clinical signs and symptoms subsided, crack and fracture root canal was filled with MTA. For the sealing procedures, MTA cement (Dentsply Meillfer, Switzerland) was used according to the manufacturer's instructions. To remove the smear layer without excessive modification of the underlying dentin was applied by 17% EDTA (EDTA Pentron, Tokyo, Japan) solution for 60s to the fractured surfaces and root canal and then washed and air-dried gently. MTA was delivered into the root canal by plugger or/and a MTA gun (Dentsply Meillfer, Switzerland). It was condensed with the bulky side of a sterile paper point within the premeasured length to the fracture line. After the root canal obturation of MTA, it was reattached using digital pressure applied over moist sterile cotton pallet.
Glass ionomer cement (Shofu, Kyoto, Japan) and/or provisional crowns were placed immediately after MTA obturation of the VRFs teeth. Provisional crowns were made by MMA resin (Shofu, Kyoto, Japan) in laboratory, and fixed with temporary cement (Temporary Hard Cement, Shofu). Those were beneficial for diagnostic purpose where the functional, stabilizing and occlusal parameters are developed to identify an optimal treatment result before the completion of definitive prosthesis. Percussion pain was examined after 3-6 months follow-up. Metal bonded porcelain crown or 4/5 crown, and hybrid resin crown was finally restored after completely asymptomatic, and continue to maintenance.

Clinical and radiographic follow-up measurements
The clinical finding were used to evaluate the outcome were percussion pain, sinus tract, gingival swelling, and pocket depth,

Results
All VRFs teeth exhibited clinical symptoms before treatment: 52 (100%) exhibited pain on percussion, 4 (7.7%) exhibited sinus tract, 4 (7.7%) exhibited gingival swelling, 4 (7.7%) recorded pocket depths of over 4 mm, and 52 (100.0%) exhibited radiographic lesions or periodontal ligament enlargement (Table 1). All endodontic treatment VRFs with MTA were followed up until after 12 months treatment. All clinical symptoms were significantly improved after treatment with MTA. The remaining teeth were showed 49 teeth (94.3%) after treatment with MTA. Table 2 summarizes the 52 clinical cases (14 maxillary premolars, 20 maxillary molars, 18 mandibular molars) treated with MTA, which were examined at regular intervals for maintenance from 8 to 90 months after treatment. After 12 months, one maxillary molar was treated by hemi-section due to re-fracture or the presence of a sinus tract. The remaining teeth caused no discomfort and were asymptomatic over a mean period of 38.9 + 22.9 months (range 8-90 months).

Discussion
MTA is the most biocompatible endodontic cement material, able to promoting tissue regeneration [21][22][23]. Recently, MTA was used for root fracture repair. The use of MTA in intra-alveolar root fractures was described in some case reports. Eraden et al. [24] and Kusgoz et al. [25] reported the repair of horizontal root fracture sealing with MTA. During a follow-up period of 1 to 3 years, all teeth showed excellent clinical and radiographic healing. Yildirin and Gencoglu observed that the area of the MTA and fracture line was fully surrounded with new hard tissue formation. Healing with the interposition of connective tissue was found in the 10-year follow-up radiographic although MTA was extruded between the fragment [26]. Kim et al initially identified 22 teeth in 21 patients who had horizontal intra-alveolar root fractures and who had received endodontic treatments with MTA, 17 teeth exhibited healing of the root fracture and 2 teeth showed interposition of granulation tissue [27].
Furthermore, Taschieri et al. reported that 10 incomplete vertical root fracture repair surgical procedures were performed [28]. At 12-months follow-up, all cases remained successful. Hadrossek et al also reported the re-implantation with MTA repair VRFs teeth could be kept in situ after 2 years [29]. Those data shows MTA was recommend to repair VRFs by preparing a groove along the entire vertical fracture, placing MTA in the groove, and covering it with a resolving membrane.
This study follows the long-term treatment and check-ups of the intra-oral cementation of 52 VRFs teeth after restored with MTA obturation. The total of 49 (94.3%) teeth were improved the clinical symptoms, and continue to the occlusal function after restoration. Our data shows that VRFs teeth treated by MTA may be functioned successfully from 8 to 90 months period. The results favorable factors in the present study, the infection removal, the biological affinity and the adhesive force of MTA can be considered. Infected root canal treatment of principle, it is needless to say that in the removal of root canal infection source. It is considered the infected dentin removal in the VRFs will affect the clinical outcome. In the treatment protocol, infection dentin removed until just before the periodontal ligament around fractures or crack was visible in the enlarged field of view through the use of DOM. As much as possible removal of the infected dentin is related to also lead to the strengthening of the MTA Biocompatibility of MTA for periodontal tissue has been reported

Number of total case (%)
percussion pain (%) and has been considered sufficient for use in soft tissue in procedures such as intentional replantation, retro-filling in root surgery, and repair of the perforation. MTA is a bioactive silicate cement is nonirritating to periapical tissue and also induces and also induces the regeneration of cementum and the PDL [30][31][32][33]. MTA can stimulate hard tissue deposition when used as a root-end filling materials [34]. When the cement was experimentally placed as a root-end filling in dogs or nonhuman primates, the histologic regeneration of the periodontal architecture was a frequent finding [35,36]. Several studies have shown that MTA placed as a root-end filling material promotes the regeneration of the PDL through a complex process of biologic repair [32,37]. Histological sections revealed biologic closure by the synthesis of new cementum and the regeneration of the PDL in the absence of inflammation.
Furthermore, MTA might stimulate PDL fibroblasts to display the osteogenic phenotype and promote the production of osteonectine, osteopontine, and increase alkaline phosphatase levels [38,39]. Our data shows that all treatment case was improved the percussion pain after until 6 months. Those clinical symptoms were support from the resistance to vertical root fracture of roots. MTA-obturation root canals demonstrated a significantly greater resistance to vertical root fracture. This can be explained as follows: MTA sets through a hydration reaction of the calcium silicates, which forms a colloidal gel that turns that into a hard structure in 2 h 45 min [13]. This setting reaction is complex but mainly involves the formation of di-calcium and tri-calcium silicate hydrates rapidly and is responsible for the increase in strength over the subsequent week [40]. I t is likely that tissue fluid may penetrate through these tubules and reach the MTA root filling. The result is the formation of a hydroxyapatite-like layer at the interface between dentine and MTA root fillings as demonstrated previously [41].
Tooth crack and VRFs in endodontic treated teeth are most serious complication, and VRFs have a poor prognosis and usually result in tooth extraction. In the present study, it is the first report to observe the long-term clinical results as an intra-oral cementation method with MTA obturation for VRFs tooth. The success rates of 94.3% allow this method to be a reliable option for restoring missing teeth. In conclusion, these results showed the MTA-obturation adhesion methods using ODM and ultrasonic instrument was effective therapy for vertical root fractures teeth without extraction of the tooth.