Proximate and microbiological compositions of some foods and vegetable from food vendors at Lagos street in Benin city

The objective of this study was to determine the proximate and microbiological compositions of some foods (cooked fried rice and moi-moi) and vegetable (pumpkin– Telfairia occidentalis) commonly sold at Lagos Street in Benin City, Edo State, Nigeria. The moisture content was highest in the vegetable with 66.64 ± 1.23% and lowest in the fried rice with 23.73 ± 0.6%. Moi-moi had the highest protein and ash contents (43.63 ± 0.43% and 1.54 ± 0.10%). The vegetable had the highest fibre content of 9.07 ± 0.10%). Fried rice had the highest carbohydrate content of 73.98 ± 1.53%. The total heterotrophic bacteria count was highest in the moimoi (7.1×105 ± 0.2 cfu/g) and lowest in the vegetable with 3.3×105 ± 0.1 cfu/g. The fungal counts ranged from 1.1×105 ± 0.1 cfu/g to 2.8×105 ± 0.2 cfu/g. Total coliform count was highest in the vegetable at 1.8×103 ± 0.1 cfu/g). The microorganisms isolated include Staphylococcus aureus, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Escherichia coli, Enterobacter aerogenes, Bacillus subtilis, Streptococcus sp, Klebsiella sp, Vibrio cholerae, Micrococcus sp, Penicillium sp, Fusarium, sp and Aspergillus niger. Staphylococcus aureus was the most prevalent microorganism (17.9%) and Vibrio cholerae and Micrococcus sp were the least prevalent microorganisms (1.8%) in the food samples. The presence of microorganisms in foods sold by food vendors at Lagos Street is an important health issue and could lead to possible spread of food – borne diseases.


Introduction
Many urban dwellers obtain a significant portion of their diet from street foods which increase the street food demand in major cities [1]. The preparation and sale of street foods is an age-old activity and has reached new dimensions as a result of rapid urbanization [2]. The safety and shelf life of these street foods, some ready-to-eat, depend upon the interaction of chemical, physical and microbial factors [3]. Street foods are foods and beverages that are sold by street vendors or hawkers and the foods and beverages could be raw or cooked [4]. They include starchy samples of maize, cassava, rice, plantain and yam; legumes like cowpea and groundnut, vegetables like tomatoes, onions, pepper, carrots, pumpkin etc and animal protein like goat meat, beef and various types of fishes [4]. Street foods displayed can be contaminated easily by dust, exhaust, smoke, insects, hands of intending buyers and climatic elements [2]. Street food vending is a large source of employment in many cities of developing countries [5], contributing significantly to household incomes [6]. Street vendors are often poorly educated, unlicenced, untrained in food hygiene practices and they work under unsanitary conditions with little or no knowledge about the causes of food borne diseases [7]. Most of the foods are not protected from flies which may carry food borne pathogens like Bacillus sp, Staphylococcus sp, E. coli, Clostridium sp, Vibrio sp, Campylobacter sp, Listeria sp and Salmonella sp [8].
A social pattern characterized by increase mobility and large itinerary workers due to urbanization has caused less family and home centred activities. This situation has resulted in more street vended ready-to-eat foods taken outside home [9]. The busy and overpopulated Lagos Street in the centre of Benin City is a commercial area where street food vendors thrive in business. Foods are often exposed near the road and vehicular emission is a major source of pollution of M Ltd UK) for total heterotrophic count, Eosin Methylene Blue Agar (EMB) (Lab M Ltd UK) for total coliform count and Potato Dextrose Agar (PDA) (Lab M Ltd UK) with chloramphenicol for total fungal count. The NAr plates were incubated at 37°C for 24 h, EMB agar for 37°C for 24 h and PDA at 25°C for 72 h. All media used were prepared according to manufacturers' instructions. Confirmation of coliform organisms was carried out by inoculating colonies into lactose broth with Durham tubes at 37°C for 48 h to evaluate gas formation [9]. The lactose broth in the tubes with gas was streaked out on EMB agar at 37°C for 24 h. After incubation all discrete colonies on NA, EMB agar and PDA were counted using a Techmel and Techmel colony counter and expressed as cfu/g. Bacterial isolates were identified on the basis of cultural morphology and biochemical tests according to Bergey's Manual of Determinative Bacteriology [11] and fungal isolates were identified on the basis of their macroscopic and microscopic characteristics [12].

Proximate analyses
The moisture, protein, crude fiber, fat, ash and carbohydrate (by difference) contents were analyzed according to the AOAC [13] method. The moisture was determined by drying the samples in a hot air oven at 150℃ for 3 h until a constant weight was determined. Protein content was by Kjeldahl method (total % Nitrogen×6.25 conversion factor). Ash content was determined by incinerating 5 g of the samples in a muffle furnace at 550℃ for 4 h, cooling in a dessicator and weighing. Fat content was determined by Soxhlet extraction method in ethyl ether. Crude fiber was determined by the enzymaticgravimetric method. All the proximate analyses were carried out in triplicates and calculated in percentage.

Statistical analysis
Results were calculated in triplicate data and expressed as mean ± standard deviation. The values were analyzed statistically using analysis of variance (ANOVA) at 5% level of significance and least significant difference (LSD) was used to compare the means [14].
Nine bacterial species and three fungal species were isolated from the food samples (Table 3). Staphylococcus aureus, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, Bacillus subtilis, Klebsiella sp and Aspergillus niger were present in all the food samples. E.coli and Vibrio cholerae were only encountered in the pumpkin vegetable and Enterobacter sp was only found in the moi-moi. Penicillium sp, Fusarium sp and Streptococcus sp were absent in the pumpkin vegetable.
In Table 4 is presented the frequency and percentage occurrence of the microorganisms in the food samples. Staphylococcus aureus was the most prevalent microorganism (17.9%) and Vibrio cholerae and Micrococcus sp were the least prevalent species with percentage prevalence of 1.8%

Discussion
The food samples analyzed in this study are the frequently purchased street vended foods in Lagos streets. The fried rice and moimoi are purchased early from food vendors on the way to work and the vegetables when returning from work. The nutrients derived in these ready to eat street vended foods are of importance and determines the quality of the food [15]. The moisture content of a food sample shows the shelf life stability of the product. The moisture contents of the food samples were high. Moisture content in excess of 14% in foods has danger of bacteria action and mould growth to produce undesirable changes [16]. The moisture content of the pumpkin was within the range of 58-93% of leafy vegetables [17]. The higher moisture content of the pumpkin when compared to the other food samples show that the vegetable has low storage capacity and is easily perishable, though the high moisture content will enhance food digestion and peristaltic movement on consumption [18]. The protein content of the moi-moi in    [20]. The protein quality of a diet is usually a measure of the ability to promote growth. This makes the moi-moi nutritionally balanced when purchased with the fried rice which is of low protein content but high carbohydrate content. Animal protein is seldom affordable by the poor in developing countries. Plants sources like moi-moi provide a cheap source of protein [21].
This study revealed a low fat content when compared to other studies for moi-moi at 15.25% [19] and 4.80% [20], cooked rice at 4.00% [22] and vegetable at 14.04% [18]. High lipid content with high moisture as seen in the pumpkin vegetable in this study increases the chances for rancidity and thus decreases the shelf life of the food [23]. The lower ash content in the fried rice and vegetable samples when compared to other studies is indicative of low mineral content [24] and hence influences its quality. The crude fiber content in the pumpkin was lower than the 10.36% in the study of Effiong et al. [18]. The fiber content is beneficial as fiber in food helps eliminate bile acids, lower body cholesterol and creates variation in feacal bulk and transit time [16]. High fiber diet intake prevents diet related diseases like cardiovascular disease, cancer of the colon and diabetes [25]. Diet with high fiber content have been used for weight control and fat reduction as it provides satiety and thereby reduces the amount of energy given food that would be consumed [26]. This could be an advantage as cooked pumpkin and salad vegetables are often sold along with fried rice, moi-moi and beans at Lagos Street.
The high microbial count recorded in the food samples could be linked to a number of factors such as improper handling and processing conditions, use of contaminated water during cooking, cross contamination of raw materials used during production, use of dirty processing utensils and unhygienic nature of food vendors [2]. The mean microbial count from the study is unacceptable as it exceeds the recommended standard of ˂10 5 cfu/g for ready-to-eat foods [27,28]. The microorganisms isolated in this study were in agreement with the studies of Odu and Imaki [9], Akinnibosun and Airiohuodion [8] and Ike et al. [2]. The presence of E.coli in the pumpkin vegetable indicates direct or indirect faecal contamination and this point to poor hygiene practices by the food vendors. E.coli strains pose food safety problems as they are all enterotoxigenic and cause gastroenteritis [29]. Staphylococcus aureus was the most prevalent microorganism and its presence in the food is an indication of excessive human handling [30]. Contamination of ready-to-eat by Staphylococcus aureus can be prevented through the use of latex gloves to reduce excessive human hand contact [31]. Presence of Bacillus, Klebsiella and Pseudomonas species, known to be environmental contaminants in the food samples could be due to the high rate of exposure of the food items by the food vendors to airborne and dust contaminants [2]. They were isolated in all the food samples. Bacillus sp produces toxins that withstand high temperature and are spore forming. Ingestion of the toxin-containing food causes nausea, vomiting, abdominal cramps and diarrhea [32]. Klesiella sp causes severe infections that include meningitis, bronchitis, pneumonia and urinary tract infections in human [33].
Aspergillus niger was the most prevalent fungus and its presence in the food may be hazardous to public health. Aspergillus species cause aspergillosis in patients with weakened immune systems [34]. According to Mensah et al. [35], 37.5% of the vendors in Accra harboured at least one enteric bacterium such as E.coli and Salmonella. This is in agreement with the findings of this study where there were three enteric organisms among the nine bacteria isolated. The food vendors continuously stay by road sides in order to attract consumers thereby exposing the food to microbial contamination. The microbiological quality and safety of ready-to-eat vended foods are influenced by processing steps and storage conditions that introduce microorganisms [9], also the poor hygiene and handling by the vendors increase the contamination of the foods. The presence of Vibrio cholerae in the pumpkin vegetable showed contamination of the water used in processing the vegetable or insufficient heating of the vegetable. Effective cooking would destroy their presence [36]. Since most fresh vegetables retain their freshness for a short time, it is always better to buy vegetables in morning or evening hours depending on harvesting pattern [37]. The presence of the highest number of microbial isolates in the moi-moi depicts deplorable poor hygiene and sanitary practices employed in the processing and handling of the food and also the use of poor quality grains and leaves [38].

Conclusion
The isolation of pathogenic microorganisms from the commonly purchased foods vended in Lagos Street could pose serious health hazards to consumers. Poor handling, poor hygiene and care during and after preparation, poor storage and preservation of food and exposure of vended foods were some of the reasons for contamination of the street ready-to-eat food. Health education of vendors and consumers of street vended foods is therefore necessary in order to maximally reduce contamination of foods.